The traditional Libertarian argument is that you’ve a right to swing your fists as much as you want to (that’s a manly metaphor, for the slow readers amongst us) provided you don’t hit another’s nose.
Regular poster Teri is an awesome combination of left, right and libertarian. I regularly disagree with her, but she knows her mind and responds accordingly.
She said, on a recent thread:
I also think I should have the right not to wear a seatbelt or a helmet. I hate being micro-managed.
Well, she’s right and wrong.
I am not making up a single word of my response to this. Not that I normally do, but I might well spin a detail to tell a better story. I try to be a story-teller on this blog as well as a blogger. On stories I tell, I certainly shift the facts to protect people’s real-life identities; I also do so, as I say, to tell a better story. A conversation that occurred over two months might be condensed into 20 words. So be it.
Here I shall give you the unvarnished facts.
I was 17. Driving. With my mother. Oh God.
What worse punishment can you inflict upon a young man (or an older woman)?
She has the terror of not possessing his reflexes, and not knowing if he really knows what he’s doing. It wasn’t until years later that I realized that wheeling into a tight parking space at speed and relying on a downshift and brake combination to stop me was very disturbing to women. So much for sensitive Wolfe.
But leave that aside. The (true) story is this. I was approaching a red light in our aging 1980’s car. My mother screamed “STOP!!!”. I braked, being very uncertain as to what was happening and modulating the breaking so as to ensure we slowed then stopped about a foot short of the line.
I had about 250 milliseconds to recover from that unholy screech when WHAM!
WHAM!
WHAM!
WHAM!
we were run into repeatedly. Three to four times.
Whiplash city. Dull pain in my lower back.
Somehow, my brain processed the fact that I had to keep my foot on the brake.
Shaken, I picked up my glasses. My mother did the same. Then we realized we’d put each others’ glasses on.
After an embarrassing moment with my first cross-dressing experience (are glasses really gender-oriented?) we exchanged them. I put the vehicle in park, turned off the ignition, and asked her to call the police on her Cell.
I staggered out, wincing. I approached the 1970’s vehicle that had hit us, painted a hideous, well, forgive me, but this was the color… a hideous “shit brown”.
The elderly lady (probably 70 to 80) inside was semi comatose. I opened the door. I said loudly “Ma’am are you OK?” I repeated it, twice. (that means 3 times in total for those who’ve suffered from socialized education).
She stirred, and looked up at me perkily.
“Hi there!” she said.
“You’re ok, ma’am?” I was angry at her for smashing into me, but I was disoriented more than anything else. I did have enough presence to know I needed to call an ambulance, stat, if she was hurt.
She looked up at me and smiled sunnily, exposing her British dentist’s work.
“Oh…” she said, feebly, still smiling.
“Are you all right ma’am?”
“I braked.”
“Yes ma’am, but you didn’t stop.”
I was somewhat glacial.
She responded “Well, I wasn’t wearing this silly seatbelt and my head hit the window [windshield]….”
Yeah.
OK. So she didn’t want to wear her seatbelt so she slammed into me again and again and again.
My back is still a bit f-d up from that.
It was her choice; I paid the cost.
Sure, I could massively sue her, but why the #$(*) do that?
The
WHAM
WHAM
WHAM
where she kept bumping my car forward and slamming into me?
Yeah, she had the right to do so, I paid the cost.
And that’s where I draw the line. Where someone else has a right, and you pay the cost.
Especially when it’s something so trivial.
That’s why I moved towards being a conservative, rather than a libertarian. Libertarians were filled with imaginative but not very realistic solutions, mainly involving me suing her. She was an elderly lady. I didn’t want to do that.
Nevertheless, her choice of not wearing a seatbelt meant additional injury to me.
-wolfe